Not quite. The £55 billion hole in the UK’s finances is to be met by a combination of spending cuts and tax increases, in a ratio of approximately 55% to 45% respectively. In 2010, George Osbourne funded 80% of the Government’s financial hole from spending cuts and 20% from tax rises.
The Chancellor treads a difficult and narrow path between reassuring financial markets about the state of the nation’s finances, to keep borrowing costs under control, while not inflicting too much pain on individuals and public services given the shaky economic outlook. The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) said the UK economy was already in recession and forecast further weakness in 2023, with economic output dropping 1.4%.
The outlook for the consumer remains difficult. The OBR predicted house prices would fall 9% between the fourth quarter of 2022 and the third quarter of 2024, from a combination of higher mortgage rates and the economic downturn [3]. This will hit confidence. Households are likely to be worse off for two years in row, with disposable income set to dip 4.3% in the 2022/23 tax year.
However, it does appear that the Chancellor has achieved his primary aim, with financial markets’ reaction to the Statement proving relatively muted. The yield on government bonds – typically a barometer for the credit-worthiness of the UK Government – remained largely unchanged, having already dropped a long way following its spike after Kwasi Kwarteng’s ‘mini-budget’. Sterling dropped slightly but has increased 14% since its low point relative to the US dollar on the 26 September [4].
After some initial volatility, energy companies and electricity producers also shrugged off the announcement and the UK stock market was largely flat on the day.
There is no doubt that the economic backdrop for the UK remains extremely difficult. The Chancellor may have avoided the mistakes of his predecessor, but there are still external inflationary pressures and CPI is likely to stay well above the Bank of England’s 2% target throughout next year.
In keeping the gilt yield stable, the Chancellor has succeeded in ensuring mortgage rates don’t spike higher and heap more pressure on household finances. Equally, the worst of the tax rises come in 2024, rather than immediately, which should help ease short-term pressures on households.
The Chancellor has done enough to calm markets, but in the longer term he needs to generate economic growth. That is likely to prove more difficult.
Sources
[1] Autumn Statement 2022: Key points at-a-glance, BBC News, 17 November 2022
[2] Chancellor extends energy windfall tax to ‘low carbon’ generators, The Guardian, 17 November 2022
[3] Autumn Statement live: UK house prices to fall until 2024, OBR says, Financial Times, 17 November 2022
[4] Pound Sterling to US Dollar Exchange Rate chart, XE.com [accessed 17 November 2022]